Cottage Club , which began its life in the "University Cottage" on University Place, was the second club to build on Prospect. Around 1891, Cottage contemplated a plan for a clubhouse that shows the distinct influence of the Richardsonian style still popular at the time, especially in the mixing of materials and the large round towers with conical roofs (compare this design, for example, with Witherspoon and Dod halls on the campus).

This building was never constructed.