Court Club was founded in 1921, with its members taking their meals at the Nassau Inn for the first year of the club's existence. In 1923, Court moved into the venerable building that had been constructed for Cottage Club in 1892 and that had since been occupied by both Tower Club and Cloister Inn. (This building had been moved to 89 Prospect when Cottage built its current clubhouse.)

In 1927, Court purchased the building and demolished it.